[Bast-commits] r5691 - in DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk: . t
robkinyon at dev.catalyst.perl.org
robkinyon at dev.catalyst.perl.org
Fri Mar 6 15:43:50 GMT 2009
Author: robkinyon
Date: 2009-03-06 15:43:50 +0000 (Fri, 06 Mar 2009)
New Revision: 5691
Modified:
DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk/
DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk/t/98rows_prefetch.t
Log:
r5673 at rkinyon-lt-osx (orig r5672): robkinyon | 2009-03-01 00:13:38 -0500
Added more notes to the bottom of the failing testcase
Property changes on: DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk
___________________________________________________________________
Name: svk:merge
- 168d5346-440b-0410-b799-f706be625ff1:/DBIx-Class-current:2207
462d4d0c-b505-0410-bf8e-ce8f877b3390:/local/bast/DBIx-Class:3159
4d5fae46-8e6a-4e08-abee-817e9fb894a2:/local/bast/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/resultsetcolumn_custom_columns:5160
4d5fae46-8e6a-4e08-abee-817e9fb894a2:/local/bast/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/sqla_1.50_compat:5414
4d5fae46-8e6a-4e08-abee-817e9fb894a2:/local/bast/DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk:5635
9c88509d-e914-0410-b01c-b9530614cbfe:/local/DBIx-Class:32260
9c88509d-e914-0410-b01c-b9530614cbfe:/local/DBIx-Class-CDBICompat:54993
9c88509d-e914-0410-b01c-b9530614cbfe:/vendor/DBIx-Class:31122
ab17426e-7cd3-4704-a2a2-80b7c0a611bb:/local/dbic_column_attr:10946
ab17426e-7cd3-4704-a2a2-80b7c0a611bb:/local/dbic_trunk:10954
bd5ac9a7-f185-4d95-9186-dbb8b392a572:/local/os/bast/DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk:2798
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/belongs_to_null_col_fix:5244
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/cdbicompat_integration:4160
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/column_attr:5074
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/complex_join_rels:4589
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/file_column:3920
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/multi_stuff:5565
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/on_disconnect_do:3694
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/oracle_sequence:4173
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/parser_fk_index:4485
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/prefetch:5671
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/replication_dedux:4600
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/rt_bug_41083:5437
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/savepoints:4223
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/sqla_1.50_compat:5321
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/storage-ms-access:4142
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/subquery:5617
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/sybase:5651
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/versioned_enhancements:4125
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/versioning:4578
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/views:5585
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class-C3:318
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class-current:2222
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class-joins:173
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class-resultset:570
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/datetime:1716
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/find_compat:1855
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/find_unique_query_fixes:2142
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/inflate:1988
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/many_to_many:2025
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/re_refactor_bugfix:1944
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/reorganize_tests:1827
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/resultset-new-refactor:1766
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/resultset_2_electric_boogaloo:2175
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/resultset_cleanup:2102
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/sqlt_tests_refactor:2043
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/trunk/DBIx-Class:3606
fe160bb6-dc1c-0410-9f2b-d64a711b54a5:/local/DBIC-trunk-0.08:10510
+ 168d5346-440b-0410-b799-f706be625ff1:/DBIx-Class-current:2207
462d4d0c-b505-0410-bf8e-ce8f877b3390:/local/bast/DBIx-Class:3159
4d5fae46-8e6a-4e08-abee-817e9fb894a2:/local/bast/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/resultsetcolumn_custom_columns:5160
4d5fae46-8e6a-4e08-abee-817e9fb894a2:/local/bast/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/sqla_1.50_compat:5414
4d5fae46-8e6a-4e08-abee-817e9fb894a2:/local/bast/DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk:5635
9c88509d-e914-0410-b01c-b9530614cbfe:/local/DBIx-Class:32260
9c88509d-e914-0410-b01c-b9530614cbfe:/local/DBIx-Class-CDBICompat:54993
9c88509d-e914-0410-b01c-b9530614cbfe:/vendor/DBIx-Class:31122
ab17426e-7cd3-4704-a2a2-80b7c0a611bb:/local/dbic_column_attr:10946
ab17426e-7cd3-4704-a2a2-80b7c0a611bb:/local/dbic_trunk:10954
bd5ac9a7-f185-4d95-9186-dbb8b392a572:/local/os/bast/DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk:2798
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/belongs_to_null_col_fix:5244
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/cdbicompat_integration:4160
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/column_attr:5074
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/complex_join_rels:4589
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/file_column:3920
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/multi_stuff:5565
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/on_disconnect_do:3694
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/oracle_sequence:4173
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/parser_fk_index:4485
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/prefetch:5672
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/replication_dedux:4600
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/rt_bug_41083:5437
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/savepoints:4223
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/sqla_1.50_compat:5321
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/storage-ms-access:4142
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/subquery:5617
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/sybase:5651
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/versioned_enhancements:4125
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/versioning:4578
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/DBIx-Class/0.08/branches/views:5585
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class-C3:318
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class-current:2222
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class-joins:173
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class-resultset:570
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/datetime:1716
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/find_compat:1855
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/find_unique_query_fixes:2142
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/inflate:1988
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/many_to_many:2025
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/re_refactor_bugfix:1944
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/reorganize_tests:1827
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/resultset-new-refactor:1766
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/resultset_2_electric_boogaloo:2175
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/resultset_cleanup:2102
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/branches/DBIx-Class/sqlt_tests_refactor:2043
bd8105ee-0ff8-0310-8827-fb3f25b6796d:/trunk/DBIx-Class:3606
fe160bb6-dc1c-0410-9f2b-d64a711b54a5:/local/DBIC-trunk-0.08:10510
Modified: DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk/t/98rows_prefetch.t
===================================================================
--- DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk/t/98rows_prefetch.t 2009-03-06 15:43:40 UTC (rev 5690)
+++ DBIx-Class/0.08/trunk/t/98rows_prefetch.t 2009-03-06 15:43:50 UTC (rev 5691)
@@ -12,16 +12,16 @@
my $schema = DBICTest->init_schema();
$schema->storage->debug(1);
my $no_prefetch = $schema->resultset('Artist')->search(
- undef,
- { rows => 3 }
+ undef,
+ { rows => 3 }
);
my $use_prefetch = $schema->resultset('Artist')->search(
- undef,
- {
- prefetch => 'cds',
- rows => 3
- }
+ undef,
+ {
+ prefetch => 'cds',
+ rows => 3
+ }
);
my $no_prefetch_count = 0;
@@ -29,21 +29,76 @@
is($no_prefetch->count, $use_prefetch->count, '$no_prefetch->count == $use_prefetch->count');
-# The fix is to, when using prefetch, take the query and put it into a subquery
-# joined to the tables we're prefetching from. This might result in the same
-# table being joined once in the main subquery and once in the main query. This
-# may actually resolve other, unknown edgecase bugs. It is also the right way
-# to do prefetching. Optimizations can come later.
-
TODO: {
- local $TODO = "This is a difficult bug to fix, workaround is not to use prefetch with rows";
- $no_prefetch_count++ while $no_prefetch->next;
- $use_prefetch_count++ while $use_prefetch->next;
- is(
- $no_prefetch_count,
- $use_prefetch_count,
- "manual row count confirms consistency"
- . " (\$no_prefetch_count == $no_prefetch_count, "
- . " \$use_prefetch_count == $use_prefetch_count)"
- );
+ local $TODO = "This is a difficult bug to fix, workaround is not to use prefetch with rows";
+ $no_prefetch_count++ while $no_prefetch->next;
+ $use_prefetch_count++ while $use_prefetch->next;
+ is(
+ $no_prefetch_count,
+ $use_prefetch_count,
+ "manual row count confirms consistency"
+ . " (\$no_prefetch_count == $no_prefetch_count, "
+ . " \$use_prefetch_count == $use_prefetch_count)"
+ );
}
+__END__
+my $rs1 = $schema->resultset('Artist')->search(
+ undef, {
+# join => 'cds',
+ },
+);
+warn ${$rs1->as_query}->[0], $/;
+{ my @x = $rs1->all; warn "$#x\n"; }
+
+my $rs2 = $schema->resultset('Artist')->search(
+ undef, {
+ from => [{
+ me => $rs1->as_query,
+ }],
+ prefetch => 'cds',
+ },
+);
+
+warn ${$rs2->as_query}->[0], $/;
+{ my @x = $rs2->all; warn "$#x\n"; }
+
+__END__
+The fix is to, when using prefetch, take the query and put it into a subquery
+joined to the tables we're prefetching from. This might result in the same
+table being joined once in the main subquery and once in the main query. This
+may actually resolve other, unknown edgecase bugs. It is also the right way
+to do prefetching. Optimizations can come later.
+
+This means that:
+ $foo_rs->search(
+ { ... },
+ {
+ prefetch => 'bar',
+ ...
+ },
+ );
+
+becomes:
+ my $temp = $foo_rs->search(
+ { ... },
+ {
+ join => 'bar',
+ ...
+ },
+ );
+ $foo_rs->storage->schema->resultset('foo')->search(
+ undef,
+ {
+ from => [
+ { me => $temp->as_query },
+ ],
+ prefetch => 'bar',
+ },
+ );
+
+Problem:
+ * The prefetch->join change needs to happen ONLY IF there are conditions
+ that depend on bar being joined.
+ * How will this work when the $rs is further searched on? Those clauses
+ need to be added to the subquery, not the outer one. This is particularly
+ true if rows is added in the attribute later per the Pager.
More information about the Bast-commits
mailing list